In a shocking development in the case of missing 20-month-old Aya Reynolds, police have discovered blood belonging to the child inside the home of her father, Justin Deietro. The revelation comes nearly six years after Aya vanished under suspicious circumstances, igniting a media frenzy and a relentless search for answers.
On the night of December 17, 2011, Aya was put to bed by her father in their Waterville, Maine home. When Justin checked on her the next morning, she was gone. As the search expanded, police initially suspected foul play, a theory that has gained traction over the years.
Authorities found blood on Aya’s slippers and a baby doll in the house, raising serious questions about the events of that night. Justin, along with his girlfriend and sister, has maintained that Aya was abducted, claiming that someone broke into their home. However, investigators have expressed skepticism about this account, stating that no signs of forced entry were found.
Aya’s mother, Trista Reynolds, has been vocal in her quest for justice, expressing her anguish over the loss of her daughter. “Tell me what happened to my daughter,” she pleaded, echoing the sentiments of a heartbroken parent desperate for answers.
In a recent exclusive interview, Justin broke his silence, suggesting that he believes Aya was taken by someone known to them. “I thought it was kind of weird that Trista passed through Waterville that same morning,” he claimed, pointing fingers at his ex-partner. The tension between the parents has only intensified over the years, with accusations flying back and forth.

Despite the blood evidence found in his home, Justin insists he has nothing to hide. “I’ve never done anything wrong,” he stated, maintaining his innocence as the investigation continues to unfold.
As the legal proceedings evolve, a judge recently declared Aya legally dead, a painful acknowledgment for Trista, who plans to pursue a wrongful death lawsuit against Justin. “She needs to have justice,” Trista declared, vowing to keep fighting for her daughter’s memory.
The case remains open, with authorities urging anyone with information to come forward. The community, still reeling from the tragedy, holds onto hope that the truth will eventually emerge. As the investigation deepens, the shadows of suspicion linger over the family, leaving many to wonder what truly happened to little Aya Reynolds on that fateful night.
